Receiving a Yuletide-winning fic is awesome, but once I've read it, I have to leave it for a while before I can reread it.

Writing a Yuletide-winning fic means that I can start every day for the next month or longer by reading kudos notifications and comments about what a good writer I am. It's like the gift that keeps on giving.

So I pick Give, but obviously what I really want is both.