I feel like there's this whole abstract conversation going on around 'is Nazi RPF okay and if not, how does it differ from these other morally suspect things etc etc' when the real truth is that it could probably have been nominated by a different person asking for different things and gone through just fine.

It's Nazi RPF being requested by someone who's clearly a white supremacist that's the issue here. I'm pretty sure we'd all run screaming from writing underage RPF for Ian Watkins as well.