You're right that I apparently got mixed up with threads and subthreads here and you did acknowledge that they said that and that it wasn't reasonable. But as far as I can tell you're also still maintaining that the post overall is reasonable and you don't understand why people got so annoyed by it, and that's why people are still arguing with you.

The post, to be fair, probably isn't worthy of all the wank it caused and is continuing to cause, but it also has such a uselessly broad definition of shaming that I think any legitimate point it could have made is pretty well buried.