yuletide_coal | It's a Coal (w)rap Battle

It's a Coal (w)rap Battle

Sign-up or edit your offers/requests till October 27

Writing Post : http://yuletide-coal.dreamwidth.org/4047.html

Yet too many times, especially in the anime and manga section, the two are conflated. A fandom will have manga and an anime and there's only one tagset for the fandom overall.

I'm requesting a fandom that has both, so I signified that I'm good with either as a source.

Yep. Using TnC as an example again, it was nominated as the VN but now appears in both the Video Games and Anime & Manga categories. Probably it should have been nominated with a parenthetical to differentiate it.

Maybe I'm misremembering, but wasn't this brought up on the admin comm and people basically said there was no noteable difference?

I mean, idk what you count as "noticeable difference," but Akira can't get raped to death with a screwdriver in the anime.

Weren't there people specifically arguing against them being the same otherwise the fandom would have been over the limit?

No, TnC is definitely under the limit with the VN and anime combined, and there wasn't any evidence debate. You may be thinking of something else -- possibly DMMD? Which is by the same company and suffers from the same sanitization in its anime.

Yes, now that you say it, I remember it was DMMD. From the descriptions here it just sounded similar. Wasn't rape vs no-rape used for DMMD as one of the evidence anime and VN aren't the same?

You're correct :)

http://yuletide-admin.dreamwidth.org/19798.html?thread=142422#cmt142422

Yule mods can't do anything about the categories tags appear under, that's all on the archive which categories are set for the tag.

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

It's a Coal (w)rap Battle

Re: specific complaint in letters/requests

Re: specific complaint in letters/requests

Re: specific complaint in letters/requests

Re: specific complaint in letters/requests

Re: specific complaint in letters/requests

Re: specific complaint in letters/requests

Re: specific complaint in letters/requests

Re: specific complaint in letters/requests

Re: specific complaint in letters/requests